eBay and Amazon are two of the largest online marketplaces, each catering to different business models and selling strategies. Choosing the right platform depends on factors like pricing, product type, and long-term goals.

This guide breaks down the key differences, pros, and cons to help you decide which platform best suits your business.

Overview of eBay vs Amazon

While both Amazon and eBay are two of the biggest online marketplaces, they operate differently. eBay is a flexible platform known for its auction-style and fixed-price listings, making it ideal for selling both new and used products. It allows sellers more control over pricing and customer interactions, attracting a significant market share of online shoppers who appreciate this flexibility.

On the other hand, Amazon is a retail giant focused on fast shipping, convenience, and brand-name products. It prioritizes new, high-demand items and offers services like Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) for streamlined logistics. Amazon's operational model is similar to a traditional retail store, emphasizing direct sales of products and a structured pricing strategy.

The key difference is that eBay caters to a broader range of products, including secondhand and collectibles, while Amazon emphasizes new, branded merchandise with a more structured selling approach.

Selling on eBay: Pros and Cons

eBay offers a flexible selling experience with lower fees and greater control, making it a great choice for certain types of sellers. The marketplace is often likened to a virtual garage sale where sellers can offload a variety of personal items, including vintage goods and collectibles. However, it also requires more hands-on management compared to Amazon.

Pros:

• Lower selling fees compared to Amazon, allowing sellers to keep more profit.

• More control over listings, pricing, and customer interactions.

• Ideal for unique, second-hand, or collectible items that may not sell as well on Amazon.

• No strict fulfillment requirements—sellers can handle their own shipping methods and policies.

Cons:

• Slower sales cycle, especially for auction-style listings, as buyers may wait for bidding to end.

• Less built-in trust compared to Amazon, where customers often expect brand-new, verified products.

• More hands-on management is required for shipping and customer service, as eBay does not offer fulfillment solutions like Amazon FBA.

eBay is best suited for sellers who want control over their business and have the time to manage listings and customer service. However, those looking for fast sales and automated fulfillment may find Amazon a better fit.

Selling on Amazon: Pros and Cons

Amazon provides sellers with access to a massive customer base and a streamlined selling process, but it comes with higher fees and stricter policies.

Pros:

• Huge customer base and strong brand trust, leading to higher conversion rates.

• Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) allows for hands-off shipping and returns, making it easier for sellers to scale.

• Faster sales cycle, especially for high-demand and impulse-buy products.

• More visibility for new sellers thanks to Amazon’s algorithm-driven search and recommendation system.

Cons:

• Higher Amazon selling fees, including referral fees and additional charges for FBA services.

• Strict seller policies with the risk of account suspensions for even minor infractions.

• Intense competition, including from Amazon’s private-label products, which can dominate search results.

Amazon is ideal for sellers looking for a high-volume, fast-moving business model with minimal fulfillment hassles. However, it requires careful management to navigate fees, policies, and competition.

eBay vs Amazon: Fees & Costs Comparison

When choosing between eBay and Amazon for your selling platform, it's essential to understand their fee structures, as they can significantly impact your profitability.

eBay Seller Fees:

• Insertion Fees: eBay provides up to 250 zero insertion fee listings per month for sellers without a store subscription. Beyond this limit, an insertion fee of $0.35 per listing applies.

• Final Value Fees: When an item sells, eBay charges a final value fee, which is a percentage of the total sale amount (item price plus shipping). For most categories, this fee ranges from 2.5% to 15%, depending on the item category and whether you have an eBay Store subscription. Compared to eBay's fee categories, Amazon charges an annual subscription fee for Prime membership, which offers various benefits to foster consumer loyalty and trust.

• Additional Fees: Optional listing upgrades, such as bold titles or international site visibility, incur extra charges.

Amazon Seller Fees:

• Selling Plans:

  • Individual Plan: $0.99 per item sold, suitable for sellers with fewer than 40 sales per month.​

  • Professional Plan: $39.99 per month, offering additional tools and reports, ideal for higher-volume sellers.

• Referral Fees: Amazon charges a percentage of each sale, varying by category, typically between 6% and 45%. For most categories, the referral fee is 15%. ​

• Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) Fees: If you use FBA, additional fees apply, including fulfillment fees based on item size and weight, and monthly storage fees. For example, standard-size items incur fulfillment fees starting at $2.50 per unit. ​

Which Is Better?

Your choice between eBay and Amazon depends on your business model and preferences:

• eBay offers lower upfront costs and greater control over listings and fulfillment, making it suitable for sellers who prefer a hands-on approach and deal in unique or used items.​

• Amazon provides a larger customer base and streamlined fulfillment through FBA but comes with higher fees. It's ideal for sellers seeking automation, faster sales cycles, and access to Amazon's extensive customer network.​

Consider your product type, sales volume, and desired level of involvement in the selling process when choosing the platform that aligns best with your business goals.

eBay vs Amazon: Fulfillment & Shipping

eBay gives sellers full control over shipping, allowing them to handle orders manually or use third-party logistics services. This flexibility lets sellers choose their preferred shipping carriers, set their handling times, and offer customized packaging. However, it also requires more effort, as sellers must manage shipping, tracking, and returns themselves.

Amazon offers Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), where Amazon handles storage, packing, shipping, and customer service for a fee. FBA also grants products Prime eligibility, increasing visibility and attracting more buyers. While this automation saves time, it comes with higher costs and storage fees, especially for slow-moving inventory.

Which is better? eBay is ideal for sellers who want more flexibility and control over shipping, while Amazon’s FBA is best for those looking for automation and scalability with minimal logistical effort.

What Type of Business Is Best for Each Platform?

Choosing the right platform depends on your business model and the types of products you sell.

eBay is best for:

1. Small sellers and entrepreneurs – Ideal for those starting out or selling on a smaller scale.

2. Unique and collectible items – Great for antiques, rare finds, and one-of-a-kind products.

3. Refurbished and second-hand goods – Allows selling used electronics, vintage clothing, and more.

4. Niche markets – Works well for specialty items that may not have high demand on Amazon.

5. Sellers who want control – More flexibility over pricing, listings, and shipping methods.

Amazon is best for:

1. Brand-new products – Customers expect new, sealed items.

2. Wholesale and bulk sellers – Perfect for those sourcing in large quantities.

3. High-demand categories – Electronics, home goods, and personal care items perform well.

4. Businesses that prioritize automation – FBA handles shipping, returns, and customer service.

5. Sellers looking for scale – Amazon’s massive audience allows for rapid business growth.

Which is better for you: eBay vs Amazon? If you sell unique, second-hand, or niche products, go with eBay. If you focus on new, high-volume, or wholesale items, Amazon is the better choice.

Which Platform Should You Choose?

The right platform depends on your business goals, selling strategy, and how much control you want over the process.

Choose eBay if you prefer lower fees, more control over pricing and customer interactions, and flexibility in fulfillment. It’s a great choice for selling unique, second-hand, or collectible items, and for sellers who want to handle shipping on their own terms.

Choose Amazon if you want fast sales, access to a massive customer base, and automation through Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA). It’s ideal for selling brand-new, high-demand, or wholesale products with minimal hands-on management.

Best option? Many sellers use both platforms to maximize their reach—selling unique or used items on eBay while leveraging Amazon for new, high-volume products. This strategy allows for greater flexibility and increased sales potential.

Last Words on eBay vs Amazon

Both eBay and Amazon cater to different sellers—eBay offers flexibility and lower fees, while Amazon provides automation and a vast customer base but at higher costs. Choosing the right platform depends on your product type, budget, and time commitment. If you want control and lower fees, go with eBay; if you prefer fast sales and scalability, Amazon is the better fit.

For the best results, test both platforms to see which works best for your business.

Ready to Sell on eBay, Amazon, or Both?

Simplify your multi-channel selling with QuickSync! Effortlessly sync inventory, manage orders, and streamline your eBay and Amazon sales—all in one place.