Etsy vs Square (2026): Fees, Pros and Cons, and How to Use Both

Sunil Singh 20 Nov 2026 9 min read

You make candles, prints or jewelry, you sell at a few markets a year, and now you want to sell online too. Two names keep coming up: Etsy and Square. One is a marketplace full of shoppers. The other takes card payments at your stall and can build you a free website. On a $40 online sale, Etsy keeps about $4.25 in fees. A free Square website keeps $1.62. But that gap isn’t the whole story.

This guide compares Etsy and Square on fees, getting buyers and selling in person, explains what Etsy’s own Square connection does and doesn’t do, and shows how most makers end up using both. Every fee here comes from Etsy’s and Square’s own pages, checked in November 2026.

Etsy vs Square at a Glance

Etsy is a marketplace: you pay higher fees per sale, about 10.6% on a $40 order, but buyers are already searching there. Square is a payments and website tool: fees are lower, 3.3% + 30¢ online on its free plan and 2.6% + 15¢ in person, but it brings no shoppers. Choose Etsy to find buyers, Square for markets and your own site, or use both.

EtsySquare
What it isAn online marketplace for handmade, vintage and craft suppliesCard payments, a point-of-sale app and a website builder
Built-in shoppersYes, buyers search Etsy for productsNo, every visitor comes from you
Monthly cost$0 (Etsy Plus is an optional $10)$0 on Square Free; Plus is $49 per location
Listing fee$0.20 per listing, every 4 monthsNone
Online fees6.5% transaction fee + 3% + 25¢ processing3.3% + 30¢ (Free) or 2.9% + 30¢ (Plus)
Ad feesOffsite Ads: 15%, or 12% for bigger shops, on orders from Etsy’s adsNone, unless you buy your own ads
In personThrough a linked Square accountIts main strength: 2.6% + 15¢ on Square Free
Your own domainNo, your shop lives on etsy.comYes, on Square Plus and above
Best forNew sellers who need buyersMarket sellers, local pickup, and sellers with their own audience
Sources: Etsy Help on fees, payment processing and Offsite Ads, and Square’s fees page, checked 20 November 2026. US rates.

What Etsy and Square Actually Are

Etsy is a marketplace. You list items on etsy.com, and shoppers find them through Etsy’s search, its ads and its app. You don’t control the design much, and you share the page with other sellers, but you don’t have to find every buyer yourself.

Square is a set of business tools. Most makers know it as the card reader at a craft fair, but the same account includes a point-of-sale app, an item library and a website builder. Square used to call the website builder Square Online; it now calls it simply “websites”. On the free plan your site lives on a Square address, and connecting your own domain needs Square Plus.

You may see Square’s store builder described as a “Square marketplace” in older blog posts. It isn’t one. There’s no shared place where shoppers browse every Square seller, so a Square site only gets the visitors you send to it.

Etsy vs Square Fees

Etsy charges per listing and per sale:

  • Listing fee: $0.20 per listing. Listings last 4 months, and multi-quantity listings renew for another $0.20 each time an item sells.
  • Transaction fee: 6.5% of the item price plus delivery and gift wrap.
  • Payment processing (US): 3% + $0.25 per order, on the total including delivery and tax.
  • Offsite Ads: 15% of orders that come from Etsy’s ads on other sites, or 12% once your shop passes $10,000 in sales over a year, capped at $100 per order. Shops under $10,000 can opt out; above it, you can’t.

Square charges no listing fees. You pay a processing fee per payment, and the rate depends on your plan:

Square planMonthlyIn person (tap, dip or swipe)Online
Square Free$02.6% + 15¢3.3% + 30¢
Square Plus$49 per location2.5% + 15¢2.9% + 30¢
Square Premium$149 per location2.4% + 15¢2.9% + 30¢
From Square’s fees page, checked 20 November 2026. Plus and Premium have a 30-day free trial.

Here’s what that means on one $40 sale with free shipping and a US card:

Fees on a $40 sale: Etsy online $4.25, Etsy with an Offsite Ads order $10.25, Square website on the Free plan $1.62, Square website on Plus $1.46 plus $49 a month, in person with Square $1.39
Where the $40 sale happensFeesShare of the sale
Etsy online$2.60 (6.5%) + $1.45 (3% + 25¢) + $0.20 renewal = $4.2510.6%
Etsy online, from an Offsite Ad$4.25 + $6.00 (15%) = $10.2525.6%
Square website, Free plan$1.32 + 30¢ = $1.624.1%
Square website, Plus$1.16 + 30¢ = $1.46, plus $49 a month3.7%
In person with Square (Free), item synced from Etsy$1.04 + 15¢ + $0.20 Etsy renewal = $1.393.5%
Our calculation from the rates above. The Offsite Ads row uses the 15% rate; at 12% it’s $9.05.

Per sale, Square is always cheaper, and Square Free has no monthly fee, so there’s no break-even point to reach. Square Plus only pays for itself on fees alone once you sell more than about $12,250 a month online from one location, because it saves 0.4% against a $49 monthly charge. Most small makers who upgrade do it for the custom domain, not the rate. For the full picture of Square’s costs, see our guide to Square fees, and for Etsy’s, our breakdown of Etsy fees.

The Real Difference Between Buyers on Etsy and Square

Etsy’s higher fee pays for something Square doesn’t offer: people already shopping. Someone searching Etsy for “personalized dog collar” can find you on day one. A new Square website gets nobody until you share the link.

So the useful question isn’t “which is cheaper?”. It’s “where will my buyers come from?”

  • If you don’t have an audience yet, Etsy’s fees are the price of getting found. A $0 Square site with no visitors earns nothing.
  • If you already have regulars, such as market customers, an Instagram following or an email list, a Square site lets you sell to them without the 6.5% transaction fee or Offsite Ads.
  • Offsite Ads matter. If Etsy advertises your item elsewhere and the buyer purchases within the attribution window, you pay 15% (or 12%) on top. Shops under $10,000 a year can opt out; bigger shops can’t.

Square’s In-Person Selling Advantage

Square was built for the market stall. With a Square reader or the Square Point of Sale app, you take card payments in person for 2.6% + 15¢ on the free plan. Square’s free plan also includes pickup and local delivery for your website, which suits food sellers and anyone selling to people nearby.

For in-person sales, Etsy works with Square: you connect a Square account to your Etsy shop and sell your Etsy items through Square at markets. Etsy doesn’t add a fee on synced items sold that way, beyond the usual $0.20 auto-renewal on multi-quantity listings. One catch: if you sell an item through Square that isn’t synced from your Etsy listings, Etsy charges $0.20 per transaction, shown on your Etsy bill as a “Square manual” fee.

Etsy’s Built-in Square Connection: What It Does and Doesn’t Do

Setting it up is free. In Etsy, go to Shop Manager > Sales Channels > Sell in person, then sign up for Square or link an existing account. To send your listings across, open the Square Sales Channel page and choose Sync your Listings, or use the Sync to Square button on your Listings page. Your Etsy items then appear in the Square Point of Sale app.

Etsy's free Square connection syncs one way: Etsy listings and stock go to Square, but edits made in Square don't reach Etsy; it links one Square location, physical listings only up to 250 variations, and charges $0.20 on unsynced Square sales

It works well for one job: selling your Etsy stock at markets. Know its limits, all from Etsy’s help page:

  • It only goes one way. Etsy inventory syncs to Square, and in-person sales update Etsy. But in Etsy’s words, “Syncing from Square to Etsy is not supported at this time.” Items you add or edit in Square never reach Etsy.
  • One location. If your Square account has several locations, only one links to your Etsy shop.
  • Physical items only, and no more than 250 variations per item. Shops with only digital listings get a “Sync has unfortunately failed” message.
  • Where it’s available: sellers in the US, UK, Canada and Australia, but not US territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam.

Our guide to the best Square Etsy integration apps covers when this free connection is enough and when it isn’t.

Using Etsy and Square Together

For many makers, the honest answer to “Etsy or Square?” is both. A common setup:

  • Etsy for online discovery, where new buyers find you.
  • Square at markets and pop-ups, for card payments at the stall.
  • A Square website for regulars, so repeat customers buy without Etsy’s fees.

The problem is stock. Each one-of-a-kind piece can now sell in three places. Etsy’s free connection covers the market stall, but it breaks down when:

  • You add new stock or change a quantity in Square, which never reaches Etsy.
  • You run a second Square location, such as a shop and a market stall, and only one links to Etsy.
  • You also sell on Shopify, eBay or TikTok Shop, which Etsy’s connection doesn’t touch.

Any of these can leave a sold item still for sale somewhere else. A sync app such as QuickSync keeps Square and Etsy stock matched in both directions by SKU, so a sale in either place comes off the other. QuickSync checks Etsy for changes every 2 minutes and is listed on Square’s App Marketplace. Our guide to Etsy inventory management covers the manual options too.

Which Should You Choose?

Choosing between Etsy and Square: a new shop starts with Etsy, market sellers use Square plus Etsy, sellers with regulars add a Square website, food and local pickup suit Square, your own domain needs Square Plus, and sellers on both keep stock in sync
  • New shop, no audience yet: start on Etsy. The fees buy you buyers.
  • You sell at markets, fairs and pop-ups: Square at the stall, Etsy online, connected so stock stays right.
  • You have regulars or a social following: add a free Square website and keep Etsy for discovery.
  • Food, local pickup or delivery: Square, whose free plan includes pickup and local delivery.
  • You want your own domain and brand: Square Plus, at $49 a month per location.
  • You sell digital downloads: Etsy handles them natively. Check Square’s current support before moving them.

Weighing other website builders too? See our comparisons of Etsy vs Squarespace, Etsy vs Wix and Square vs Squarespace.

FAQs

More for Square and Etsy sellers: Square alternatives, our Square for Retail review and Black Friday tips for Etsy sellers.

Connect Etsy and Square and keep one stock count

Connect Etsy and Square, review matching SKUs and choose your source store and locations. Start Syncing aligns stock from that source; check the first update before relying on the connection.

14 days free · no card · Lite is $19 a month for two shops